11 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins, CO
Are you looking for Italian restaurants in Fort Collins? Whether you are looking for pizza, lasagna, or any Italian type of food, you have plenty of choices for it throughout the city. Check out some of the city’s unique Italian restaurants and cafes we’ve lined up for you with open rates.
Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
At the Olive Gardens in Fort Collins, you may treat your whole family to a wonderful Italian meal.
Here, broad lunch and dinner menus are excellent anytime. Olive Garden offer Antipasti, Chicken and Gnocchi, and Zuppa Toscana.
In addition, you can order gluten-free items like herb grilled salmon and rotini and try a Mediterranean flavor with the restaurant creations like linguine de mare and shrimp scampi.
As one of the best Italian restaurants in Fort Collins, the prices are reasonable based on the restaurant’s customer service, environment, and food quality.
Try the watermelon margarita for an exciting experience. Olive Garden is also an excellent place for special occasions such as birthdays.
- Address: 3905 S College Avenue, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Olive Garden
RARE Italian
RARE offers an award-winning dining experience in Old Town, Fort Collins, serving traditional Italian cuisine in a contemporary setting.
The restaurant includes fresh pasta and cheese made daily from the restaurant’s beginning, house-aged steaks, appetizers, side salad, and other delicious seasonal food with Northern Italian flavors.
The beverage menu completes the menu with exquisitely prepared cocktails, uniquely prepared wines, and beers with over 100 wines from Old World Italy and worldwide; the happy hour should not be missed.
- Address: 101 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: RARE Italian
Canino’s
Canino’s is a family restaurant started by the grandfather of the current owner of the traditional Italian restaurant, Clyde Canino. Inside, Canino’s warm, welcoming atmosphere conforms to the family’s first impression of how it has become known.
Canino’s menu is traditionally Italian cuisine, including Pasta Primavera, mozzarella sticks, Marsala, and more. In addition, the restaurant’s most popular menu is its seafood (Scampi Gaetano, Scallops Marinara, etc.)
There are also a few pizzas like Bianco, meatloaf and chili strips, sausages, mushrooms, pepperoni, and extra thick-crusted Italiano.
This place hosts social events such as birthday parties, anniversaries, and business meetings; it is considered spacious and has excellent customer service.
- Address: 613 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Canino’s
Panino’s Italian Restaurant
For over forty years, Panino’s has served the Fort Collins community, serving delicious Italian food at typical banquets.
This family-owned restaurant treats every customer who comes in as part of that family.
The restaurant serves delicious fresh food like pasta, pizza, and sandwiches prepared from locally sourced ingredients.
There is excellent customer service and reasonable food prices at this restaurant. In addition to food, Panino’s offers bottles or canned beer and Hard Seltzer drinks that will make your taste buds crave more.
You will not want to skip its oven-baked pizza with a delicious and fantastic crust. This place is perfect for carrying or eating.
- Address: 310 W Prospect Rd, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Panino’s
Domenic’s Bistro and Wine Bar
Launched in 2003, Domenic’s Bistro and Wine Bar gives an ideal balance of impeccable service, welcome decorations, and creative food for the city’s banquets.
The restaurant’s primary purpose is to provide unforgettable dining experiences (as stated on the site).
From steamed mussels, lasagna, and Italian meatballs to signature pizzas and pasta, the restaurant’s menu offers dishes inspired by different and delicious cultures, such as Italy, the Caribbean, and Greece.
In addition, from Domenic’s Bistro’s ever-evolving menu to refined wines and spirits, it consistently redefines good taste for Fort Collins.
- Address: 931 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Domenic’s Bistro
Pulcinella Pizzeria
Are you looking for various pizza restaurants in Fort Collins? This is the best place for you. It offers fresh and tasty pepperoni, pizzas, and Margarita.
You will also discover other food options such as lasagna, pasta, and bacon that have been carefully prepared with customers. It would help if you tried the authentic Italian pie of Pulcinella Pizzeria made to satisfy your taste buds.
Aside from being friendly as well as attentive, the restaurant staff is consistently ready to assist with your food choices. At the same time, the environment here is charming, and the prices can be considered reasonable.
- Address: 1119 W. Drake Rd. Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Pulcinella Pizzeria
Marchitelli’s Cucina Italiana
Located on Harmony Road in Fort Collins, Marchitelli’s Cucina Italiana is a high-end casual restaurant serving rustic Italian food and the best wines.
It offers classic food, an excellent dining experience, and excellent service as a family restaurant.
The broad menu of Marchitelli’s Cucina Italiana includes heavenly pasta and savory sauces, succulent veal, seafood, appetizers, chicken Specialties, etc.
- Address: 2400 E. Harmony Road. Ste 101A Fort Collins, C
- Check Menu: Marchitelli’s Cucina Italiana
Cacciatore at Heller’s Kitchen Fort Collins
Visit Cacciatore Heller’s Kitchen in Fort Collins for an enjoyable Italian dining experience in a stunning modern setting.
As one of the top Italian restaurants in Fort Collins, their menu comprises hand-made pizza, salads, inclusions, and desserts, displaying seasonal flavors.
The exclusive drink menu includes locally made beers, wines, and spirits. There is an attentive and well understanding staff at your service, and their goal is to guarantee an outstanding dining experience.
- Address: 1939 Jessup Dr. Suite 110, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Cacciatore at Heller’s Kitchen
Nick’s Italian
Nick’s Italian is a regionally manages restaurant in the old town of Fort Collins. Its traditional stylish Italian-American dining experience delivers a warm welcoming for all generations.
The restaurant has an open kitchen, a pizza bar, a cozy lounge, an arcade room, and a large screen TV.
Nick’s Italian is accustomed to serving Margherita pizza and Italian favorites handcrafted with the perfect set of sophisticated spices.
In addition, you can taste their delicious bucatini carbonara, chicken parmigiana, and lasagna. There is also include Happy Hour Special and full bar features.
- Address: 1100 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Nick’s Italian
Carrabba’s Italian Grill
Carrabba’s Italian Grill is an excellent restaurant that uses only the finest ingredients to make fresh and hand-made dishes to order in a live show kitchen, offering amazing Italian food passed on from family recipes.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill has a comprehensive range of delicious vegan and gluten-free options to select there.
The various dishes, pizza, bottarga, lasagna, and polenta, are deliciously crafted to capture the chef’s attention in detail. Furthermore, you can enjoy tasty food and drinks at a discount during happy hours.
- Address: 1212 Oakridge Dr, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Carrabba’s Italian Grill
Vincent Gastroteca
Looking for a constantly changing menu with unique flavors and atmosphere? Vincent Gastroteca, you can try.
From little and shared dishes to refined liquors such as wines and spirits, Vincent Gastroteca is certain to satisfy your taste buds with an outstanding dining experience.
The restaurant is perfect for a stylish dining experience with a central place and an excellent environment. Italian menu choices and restaurant brick oven pizza make you believe you have taken a meal in heaven.
- Address: 902 W Drake Rd, Fort Collins, CO
- Check Menu: Vincent Gastroteca
Note: Since all the information in this article is based on the date of publication, for some reason (health, economic, social), these businesses may be temporarily or permanently closed or moved to another location.
