11 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in Tallahassee, FL
Tallahassee, the vibrant capital of Florida, is known for its rich history, lush parks, and bustling university scene.
But did you know it’s also a hidden gem for Italian cuisine lovers? In this article, we’ll take you on a culinary journey through the best Italian restaurants in Tallahassee, where you may indulge in mouth-watering pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and delectable desserts.
From cozy trattorias to elegant fine dining establishments, Tallahassee’s Italian food scene offers diverse flavors and experiences that will transport you straight to the heart of Italy.
So, whether you’re a local or passing through, explore our guide to find the highest-rated Tallahassee Italian restaurants.
Italian Restaurants in Tallahassee
Bella Bella
For 14 years, Bella Bella has been a locally owned establishment renowned for its authentic, freshly made Italian dishes. Situated on E 5th Avenue, it has become Tallahassee’s premier destination for Italian cuisine.
Every day, skilled chefs prepare a time-honored family recipe from scratch. It ensures a delightful dining experience. Bella Bella offers catering services and takeout options for your convenience.
Join Bella Bella for lunch or dinner in their inviting dining area or enjoy a glass of wine or beer. Don’t miss their newly expanded craft beer selection, available in the “Midtown Vino Room.”
Here are some favorites:
- Sicilian Lasagna: A sauce of red peppers, Italian sausage, and onions layered with cheese and pasta, topped with melted mozzarella.
- Cannelloni: Savor pasta sheets rolled and filled with a flavorful mixture of ground veal and herbed cheeses. Creamy Alfredo sauce tops the dish.
Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen
Invite your family to experience exquisite Italian cuisine at Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen. Nestled in the Lake Breeze neighborhood, Tour of Italy Italian is a charming, small Italian eatery that could be easily overlooked.
While the interior may not be particularly striking, the restaurant makes up for it with exceptional service and delectable food. Tour of Italy boasts a diverse menu featuring specialty pasta, pizzas, seafood, salads, and various appetizers.
With seating for 50 guests, you can savor your Italian meal in the cozy dining area or unwind in the serene, enclosed patio garden. This lush, tranquil space is perfect for a relaxing dining experience.
Here are some favorites:
- Chicken Picatta: Pan-fried chicken breast topped with capers and lemon garlic butter sauce. Served over pasta.
- Bruschetta: With roasted tomatoes, fresh basil, garlic, navy beans, and olive oil.
Riccardo’s Restaurant
Riccardo’s provides a delightful dining experience for every fan of Italian cuisine. You can discover this Tallahassee Italian restaurant at 1950 Thomasville Road.
With a diverse yet manageable menu, you can easily find a dish to suit their tastes. On Thursday nights, Riccardo spices things up by adding German fare. They create a unique experience for both regulars and first-time visitors.
Here are some favorites:
- Antipasto Salad: This includes romaine, tomato, green pepper, black olives, and onion with pinwheels of ham, salami, turkey, provolone, and house dressing.
- Parmigiana Subs: Served with mozzarella and a side of marinara.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill
This chain restaurant has a family legacy of authentic recipes and quality ingredients. You’ll enjoy fresh and homemade dishes cooked to order in a lively and vibrant kitchen.
Carrabba’s Italian Grill covers whether you need catering for a large event or a cozy meal at home.
They deliver to your location and offer car-side carry-out, patio dining, and Wi-Fi. They also have vegan, gluten-free, and vegetarian options on their menu. And don’t forget to treat yourself or someone special with a gift card.
Little Italy
Situated within the Magnolia Park Courtyard, Little Italy is a hidden gem in Tallahassee. The restaurant’s ambiance features both indoor and outdoor dining options.
They offer an impressive selection of Italian-American dishes, catering to different price ranges. Their prices are reasonable and cater to every budget.
Don’t miss out on their enticing dinner or lunch specials, which include appetizers, baked specialties, pizza, soup, or salad alongside your choice of entree.
Little Italy is an excellent choice for a memorable first date or any other special dinner occasion.
Here are some favorites:
- Spinach Lasagna: housemade, with spinach and three kinds of cheese baked in this meatless casserole. It serves with marinara sauce.
- Chicken Alla Cacciatora: chicken simmered in a rich sauce of tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, garlic, red wine, and a zesty marinara sauce.
Z Bardhi’s Italian Cuisine
Z Bardhi’s has been a beloved restaurant in Tallahassee for over 20 years. It’s a cozy family-owned place near Killearn Lakes. You can sit indoors or on their covered patio for a delightful dining experience.
Enjoy their delicious Italian food while relaxing in the Florida evening. They offer a great selection of wines and cocktails at their full-service bar.
Every dinner at Z Bardhi’s comes with freshly prepared bread served with sundried rosemary, tomato, and garlic oil.
If you’re planning a special event, Z Bardhi’s can accommodate up to 80 guests inside and an additional 80 on the patio.
Their experienced staff ensures a successful and memorable catering experience, whether a small gathering or a big celebration.
Here are some favorites:
- Eggplant Florentine: This prepares fresh eggplant with spinach, mozzarella, marinara sauce, and ricotta.
- Caesar Salad: This consists of crisp romaine lettuce/croutons tossed in a classic Caesar dressing with fresh Parmesan.
IL Lusso
IL Lusso is a sophisticated Italian-inspired eatery in Downtown Tallahassee, blending the elegance of classic Chicago and New York steakhouses. Co-owned by Terry, a talented chef, the restaurant aims to bring an Italian vibe to Tallahassee.
The restaurant’s design exudes urban chic, featuring expansive windows complementing lofty ceilings. The bar area showcases a stylish fusion of wood flooring and marble accents, complete with trendy sofas.
Indulge in their lunch, dinner, and dessert options, and savor the perfect wine to complement your meal!
Here are some favorites:
- Seafood Mezzaluna: with gulf shrimp, crab, and grouper, served with a rich lobster sauce, mushroom conserva, and truffle foam.
- Insalata Gorgonzola: with iceberg wedge, gorgonzola crispy pancetta, and roasted tomato.
Brick House Restaurant & Bar
Brick House is the place to be if you’re looking for a lively spot to enjoy a mix of Italian and American flavors.
Brick House is a charming place to stay in Downtown Tallahassee. You’ll love the historic vibe of this renovated house near the Capitol Building and Florida State University.
They serve pizza, pasta, sandwiches, and more made with fresh ingredients and a touch of creativity. You can dine indoors in one of the spacious rooms, outdoors on the patio, or book a private room for a special occasion.
The restaurant is open daily for lunch, dinner, happy hour, and late-night snacks. Also, you can always find something to satisfy your cravings during Sunday brunch.
Brick House is also located near several hotels, making stopping by for a bite easy. Come and experience the fusion of Italian and American cuisine at Brick House today!
Mom & Dad’s Italian Restaurant
For over 55 years, Mom & Dad’s Italian Restaurant has been a Tallahassee landmark, offering authentic Italian food to the community.
Their menu features traditional pizzas, pasta, steaks, and special dishes made with fresh ingredients inspired by Italian classics.
Their wine list is impressive, and their service is warm and attentive. Their ambiance is cozy and elegant, perfect for a romantic dinner or a family gathering.
Mom & Dad’s Italian Restaurant is more than just a restaurant; it’s a destination for anyone who loves Italian cuisine and culture.
Here are some favorites:
- Veal Parmigiana: With marinara, Parmesan, mozzarella cheese, and angel hair pasta
- Manicotti: With seasoned ricotta cheese and marinara sauce
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana
You will love Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana in Tallahassee if you love authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. You can savor pizzas made with fresh ingredients and cooked in a wood-fired oven.
Their menu features a variety of pizzas with different toppings, calzones, paninis, salads, dessert pizzas, and gelato.
They also have craft beer and wine to pair with your pizza. Their staff is friendly and helpful, and their service is fast and efficient.
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana is the perfect spot to enjoy a tasty Italian pizza in a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Here are some favorites:
- Veal Parmigiana: With marinara, Parmesan, mozzarella cheese, and angel hair pasta
- Manicotti: With seasoned ricotta cheese and marinara sauce
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
The Olive Garden Italian chain provides an enjoyable dining experience for individuals who appreciate classic Italian cuisine in a hospitable, family-friendly atmosphere.
The restaurant is located at 1103 Apalachee Parkway and offers an extensive menu of Italian favorites. Pasta bowls, calamari, flatbreads, ravioli, ziti, rigatoni, steak Toscano, shrimp carbonara, and chicken marsala are just a few options.
In addition to these classics, Olive Garden also offers lighter Italian fare, seafood dishes, and a full bar with a range of cocktails.
Many customers have raved about Olive Garden’s exceptional service, delectable food, and generous portions. The restaurant’s inviting and comfortable atmosphere makes it an excellent choice for those wishing to indulge in a taste of Italy.
FAQs
What are the best authentic Italian restaurants in Tallahassee?
Our five best pick-up Tallahassee Itlaina restaurants are Bella Bella, Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen, Riccardo’s Restaurant, Carrabba’s Italian Grill, and Little Italy.
What types of Italian cuisine can I find in Tallahassee?
Tallahassee Italian restaurants offer classic pasta, wood-fired pizzas, seafood specialties, and delectable desserts.
Are there any Italian restaurants in Tallahassee that offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Many Italian restaurants in Tallahassee offer vegetarian & vegan options, including pasta dishes with vegetable-based sauces and dairy-free pizzas.
Do I need a reservation to dine at an Italian restaurant in Tallahassee?
While reservations are not always required, making a reservation, especially during peak dining hours or for larger parties, is a better idea to ensure a table is available.
Note: Since all the information in this article is based on the date of publication, for some reason (health, economic, social), these businesses may be temporarily or permanently closed or moved to another location.
