11 Best and Must-Try Pizza Places in Madison, WI
Madison, the capital of Wisconsin, has a diverse and vibrant culture and cuisine; its pizzas reflect that. From classic New York-style to Chicago-style and authentic Neapolitan pizzas, there is something for everyone in Madison.
With well-known spots like Ian’s Pizza, Pizza Brutta, Glass Nickel Pizza, and Grampa’s Pizzeria, you’ll easily find the perfect place to satisfy your pizza cravings.
Whether you’re searching for gluten-free or vegan options or a cozy dine-in experience, these pizza places have you covered.
Check out our complete guide to the best pizza places in Madison and discover your new favorite slice today!
Pizza Places in Madison
Ian’s Pizza
If you love pizza by the slice, you’ll love Ian’s Pizza. They have three different pizzas ranging from Signature, Classic, and Vegan.
They are famous for their Mac n’ Cheese Pizza, a cheesy delight that will make you crave more. Ian’s Pizza makes vegan pizzas with skill and attention, using only top-quality vegan products from nearby suppliers.
Ian’s Pizza is more than just a pizza place. It’s where food masterminds create new and exciting weekly recipes using the finest local ingredients. They also have one of the best salad stations, with fresh and unique options.
Ian’s Pizza operates in Madison, Milwaukee, Denver, and Seattle. Whether you want to dine in, carry out, or get it delivered, Ian’s Pizza has you covered.
Here are some favorites:
- Mac n’ Cheese: This is Ian’s most famous pizza ever! It has a creamy sauce, mac noodles, mozzarella, and cheddar cheese.
- Buff Chicken: With a creamy sauce, dry rubbed chicken, mozzarella, buffalo sauce, and bleu cheese sauce drizzled over it.
- Classic Pepperoni: This pizza is a timeless favorite, with a tomato-based sauce, mozzarella, and pepperoni.
Pizza Brutta
Located at 1805 Monroe Street, Pizza Brutta aims to create the best Neapolitan-style pizza and support the local food system and community.
Pizza Brutta would love to offer our services for your next event. Pizza Brutta tailors each event to your preferences and needs to ensure the best experience possible for you and your guests.
Pizza Brutta is one of the best pizza places in Madison for a quick snack or a cozy dinner with family/friends!
Here are some favorites:
- Roni Cups: With oregano, pepperoni cups, pickled jalapeños, and Mike’s hot honey on top.
- Nostrano: With basil, sausage, roasted red peppers, and cheese.
- Prosciutto: Rosemary, prosciutto, mozzarella, red onions, arugula, and parmesan cheese.
Glass Nickel Pizza
Visit Glass Nickel Pizza, a Madison pizza gem, for 21 years. They serve award-winning pies with subs, sandwiches, salads, homemade pasta, and lasagna.
They make their sauce and dough every morning using their award-winning recipes. And the pizza is crunchy and delicious, and unique. Sometimes that’s just the perfect treat for your taste buds.
Glass Nickel Pizza started in the Atwood neighborhood, and they are proud of their local ingredients, community service, and sustainable practices.
Here are some favorites:
- Bacon Cheeseburger: This pizza has a classic Italian sauce, house-blend cheese, bacon, beef, yellow onions, and sharp cheddar cheese for a meaty and cheesy flavor.
- Deluxe: This has a classic Italian sauce, house-blend cheese, pepperoni, yellow onions, green peppers, sausage, and mushrooms for a satisfying flavor.
- Mediterranean: This has pesto sauce, house-blend cheese, black olives, tomatoes, and feta cheese.
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies is a local favorite for New Jersey-style tomato pies. Chef Patrick DePula started his business in Sun Prairie in 2011 and has expanded to three more locations in Madison, including one on North Livingston Street.
Chef Patrick is passionate about using fresh and seasonal ingredients, which he sources from the farmer’s market. He creates delicious specials and has a loyal following for his menu items.
You can go right with the original tomato pie, which has a chewy and satisfying crust. Remember to order red wine or homemade desserts for a complete meal.
Here are some favorites:
- Fat Uncle Tony: A hearty pizza with WI mozzarella, Italian sausage, house red sauce, bacon, and fresh basil.
- Woodsman: A gourmet pizza with brown butter sautéed cremini, shiitake mushrooms and oyster, leek, truffle oil, Uplands cheese, black pepper, and chive.
- Vegan Supreme: A plant-based pizza with vegan mozzarella, red sauce, mushroom, vegan Italian sausage, green pepper, yellow onion, banana pepper, and black olive.
Grampa’s Pizzeria
Grampa’s is a must-visit artisan pizzeria on Willy Street in Madison. Love and tradition infuse every bite of their pizzas, made with a family recipe from owner Gilbert Altschul’s grampa Bill.
People love the pizzeria for its crispy, thin-crust pizza with exclusive topping and sauce combos. They also offer a gluten-free crust choice that is worth trying.
The indoor and outdoor seating ambiance is great, making it a perfect spot for a romantic dinner.
Grampa’s offers a great selection of creative pizza options, making it a cool place to sit down and enjoy a specialty pizza.
Here are some favorites:
- Finocchio: A savory pizza with tomato sauce, sausage, house-blend cheese, fennel, and Anaheim chiles for a touch of spice.
- Goomba: A creamy pizza with garlic cream sauce, house-blend cheese, mushrooms, and herbs for a burst of flavor.
- Barberini: A sweet and spicy pizza with ricotta cheese, garlic, Calabrian chiles, watercress, tomato sauce, and honey to contrast tastes.
Novanta Pizzeria
Novanta is a family-owned business since 2013. Nicolas Mattioli and his loved ones have brought authentic Neapolitan pizza to Madison.
They make their pizzas with an ancient Italian dough recipe that uses water, yeast, salt, and 00 flour. They top them with the freshest and finest ingredients, including their own mozzarella cheese.
Novanta has two convenient locations in Madison (Old Sauk Road and University Avenue). Pick the one closest to you and enjoy a hot and delicious pizza.
Here are some favorites:
- Pepperoncini: This pizza has a spicy kick with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni slices, pepperoncini peppers, garlic, and fresh basil leaves.
- Toscano: This pizza is a colorful delight with mozzarella cheese, cherry tomatoes, roasted peppers, garlic, onions, and fresh basil leaves.
- Salsiccia: This is a meat lover’s dream with mozzarella cheese, Italian sausage, garlic, mushrooms, and fresh basil leaves.
Luigi’s Pizza
At Luigi’s, you’ll enjoy pizza with hand-stretched crust and housemade toppings, from sauces to sausage.
You’ll find Luigi’s Pizza in the Midvale Plaza Shopping Center, where parking is easy. Their menu also includes sandwiches, pasta, Italian sodas, and a beer and wine list.
Luigi’s welcomes families and groups with cozy booths for couples. Need pizza for a big event? Call Luigi’s to cater your next party. Whether it’s a business lunch, a birthday, or a wedding rehearsal, Luigi’s Pizza has you covered.
Here are some favorites:
- BBQ Chicken: With BBQ sauce, mozzarella and gouda cheese, chicken, red onion, pineapple, chives, and scallions.
- Maximus: This pizza has toppings, including red sauce, mozzarella cheese, housemade sausage, pepperoni, caramelized onion, green pepper slices, and black olives.
- Wiseguy: This is a spicy treat with red sauce, Calabrian chiles, creamy burrata cheese, housemade sausage, and grated parmesan.
Lucille
You should check out Lucille’s if you are looking for a mouth-watering pizza near Wisconsin State Capitol.
This tri-level restaurant offers wood-fired and steel pan pizzas and a variety of Pan-Latin dishes.
You can also enjoy their craft beers and cocktails in a modern, rustic setting that used to be a renovated warehouse. And catch the stunning view of the capitol building from the upstairs seating area.
Here are some favorites:
- The Queen: A classic combination of fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, extra virgin olive oil, basil, and SarVecchio parmesan.
- Sausage Fest: A meat lover’s delight with tomato sauce, sausage, bacon, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, and red onion.
- Al Pastor: This steel pan pizza with aji basil cream, roasted mojo pork, mozzarella cheese, adobo sauce, and blistered tomatillo pineapple salsa. It is garnished with fresh cilantro.
Rosati’s Pizza
You can find it at Rosati’s if you love Chicago-style pizza and Italian food. As the oldest and largest pizza chain in the U.S., Rosati’s delivers to a large area, so you can savor their food wherever you are.
Discover Rosati’s in Madison at Clock Tower Court. They make quality pizzas, pasta, wings, and sandwiches with fresh, authentic ingredients and family recipes.
Make any day better with a Rosati’s pizza or calzone of your choice. They have a variety of crusts, including deep dish, double dough thin crust, and gluten-free, to suit everyone’s taste.
They have the perfect pizza for you, no matter what you’re celebrating or craving. Pick one of their delicious specialty pizzas, or create your own!
Here are some favorites:
- Chicago-Style: Enjoy their favorite item with a buttery crust, loaded with mozzarella cheese and covered with Rosati’s Chicago-Style sauce.
- The Hawaiian: Taste the tropical flavors of BBQ sauce, Canadian bacon, and pineapple on this pizza.
- Meat Mania: Satisfy your meat cravings with this pizza that has gourmet Italian sausage, meatballs, pepperoni, and bacon.
Naples 15
Naples 15 occupies Old Market Place, and Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana (AVPN) certified its pizzas.
The menu includes pizzas, pasta, salads, desserts, wine, and different delectable main courses, all crafted from top-quality ingredients and based on cherished family recipes.
And the best part about Naples 15 is that their pizzas have names of classic Italian songs.
Here are some favorites:
- Margherita DOC: A classic pizza with San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, fresh basil, salt, and extra virgin olive oil.
- Hot Salame: A spicy pizza with San Marzano tomato sauce, basil mozzarella cheese, salt, extra virgin olive oil, and Naples salami.
- Scamorza: A pizza with San Marzano tomato sauce, smoked mozzarella cheese, salt, basil, and extra virgin olive oil.
Bar Corallini
Bar Corallini is a cozy and charming Italian restaurant on Atwood Avenue. It was started by Chef Giovanni Novella, specializing in Italian cuisine and pizza.
Chef Gio prepares fresh seafood, pasta, pizza, and burrata every day from scratch at Bar Corallini.
Their pizza is especially Salsiccia type and made with the best ingredients by hand. Also, gluten-free pizza crust is available!
Here are some favorites:
- Salsiccia & Rapini: A pizza with smoked mozzarella cheese, roasted rapini, Italian sausage, Calabrian chili, mozzarella, and Parmigiano Reggiano cheese.
- Capricciosa: With San Marzano tomato sauce, Kalamata olives, mozzarella cheese, marinated mushrooms, artichokes, and prosciutto cotto.
- Zucca: With roasted Kabocha squash, creamy burrata cheese, Italian sausage, Calabrian chili, sage, and toasted pepitas.
FAQs
What are the best pizza places in Madison?
Our best pizza choices in Madison are Ian’s Pizza, Pizza Brutta, Salvatore’s Tomato Pies, Glass Nickel Pizza, and Grampa’s Pizzeria. Check out local reviews and ratings to find the perfect pizza place for your taste.
What pizza styles are in Madison?
Madison boasts a diverse pizza scene, with many spots offering various styles of pizza, including New York-style, Detroit-style, Chicago-style, and Neapolitan.
What is the average price range for a pizza in Madison?
The price of a pizza in Madison can differ depending on the toppings, size, and place. On average, you can anticipate paying between $10 and $25 for a pizza. Some locations may offer special deals or discounts, so check their websites for promotions.
Are there any pizza places in Madison that offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Several pizza places in Madison cater to dietary restrictions and preferences, offering gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese alternatives. Check the menu online to confirm the availability of these options.
Do these pizza places in Madison offer delivery?
You can typically order online or over the phone; some establishments offer contactless delivery options. Check the specific pizza place’s website or call ahead to confirm their delivery options and service areas.
Note: Since all the information in this article is based on the date of publication, for some reason (health, economic, social), these businesses may be temporarily or permanently closed or moved to another location.
