15 Best Italian Restaurants in Colorado Springs, CO (2023)

If you are a real fan of Italian food, you will find a bunch of Italian restaurants in Colorado Springs that offer a wide range of choices and excellent service.

From freshly picked vegetables and creamy homemade sauces to perfectly baked lasagna, paninis, and calzones, these places move you to Rome, Naples, and beyond. Thus, find out what are the best Italian restaurants and cafes in the city in our article.

Italian Restaurants in Colorado Springs

La Bella Vita Ristorante Italiano

Taking a quick step in life in 2012, Executive Chef Giuliano Casulli launched La Bella Vita Ristorante in Colorado Springs.

With the experience Giuliano gained from working as a sous chef at Texas restaurants and other restaurants, he got to experience and was able to start this restaurant.

La Bella Vita specializes in high Italian cuisines such as pasta, seafood, chicken, meat, beef, and desserts.

You can try their Bruschetta, Antipasto Misto, Calamari Fritti and Spaghetti Bolognese and many more. Gluten-free and vegan options are available.

Hence, La Bella Vita is one of the perfect places for an Italian food lover who wants to enjoy parties and dinner with family.

Address: 4475 Northpark Dr, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: La Bella Vita Ristorante Italiano

Paravicini’s Italian Bistro

Another favorite among Colorado Springs visitors and locals, Paravicini’s Italian Bistro, was opened in 2003 by Chef Franco Pisani. You can easily find the restaurant since it is situated in the heart of Old Colorado City.

Franco Pisani, owner, and chef of Paravicini’s Italian Bistro uses modern culinary concepts with fresh seasonal ingredients and traditional Italian recipes.

On their lunch menu, you can try Eggplant Rollatini, Tonio’s Rigatoni, and sandwiches list (Parmigiana, Sausage & Peppers, Panini Paravicini, etc.).

On the other hand, the dinner menu of Paravicini’s makes for a perfect dining experience for weddings and all your special events.

Address: 2802 W Colorado Avenue, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Paravicini’s Italian Bistro

Red Gravy

Red Gravy is an elegant setting featuring a full bar, a small outdoor patio, and a spacious indoor serving authentic Italian fare and craft cocktails.

The Red Gravy Restaurant opened in 1958 in Downtown Colorado Springs with the mission of creating a space where “culture, art, and food come together.”

The restaurant owner, Chef Eric Brenner, uses a decades-old recipe passed down through the generations.

The menu at Red Gravy includes pizza, pasta, appetizers (including garlic bread and meatball sliders), lasagna, sides (steamed vegetables and sauteed mushroom), and more.

In addition, don’t forget to try their delicious desserts like plain cheesecake and tiramisu.

Address: 23 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Red Gravy

Ristorante Di Sopra

Ristorante Di Sopra features an exclusive Italian dining experience prepared by a chef with more than thirty years of experience.

Chef Franco expertly blends the best of Italian cuisine with modern culinary concepts using traditional family recipes and the latest seasonal ingredients.

Ristorante Di Sopra, the sister restaurant of Paravicini’s Italian Bistro, is in Old Colorado City and offers panoramic views of the restaurant’s rooftop patio.

As one of the best Italian restaurants in Colorado Springs, Ristorante Di Sopra offers a range of Italian cuisines such as crab arancini, ricotta, lobster casserole, and meatballs. Along with an extensive wine list, there is a selection of classic cocktails and craft beers.

Address: 4 S 28th St, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Ristorante Di Sopra

Panino’s Downtown

In 1974, Panino’s Downtown opened on Tejon Street at Colorado Springs, and since then, the business has grown from Colorado and Minnesota to Florida.

Panino’s is the best place to go if you are in the mood for truly authentic Italian food. You may order takeout, catering, and delivery, or reserve a private event and dine in.

Panino’s has starters, pasta, salads, appetizers, calzones, and pizza, specializing in the Panino Sandwich.

Their famous Panino sandwiches blend garden vegetables, high-quality cheeses, and meats on specialty bread and are baked using fresh ingredients.

Additionally, do not forget their cocktail and happy hour menu; various choices will keep you coming back for more!

Address: 604 N Tejon Street, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Panino’s Downtown

Mollica’s Italian Market and Deli

As one of the top-rated Italian restaurants in Colorado Springs and a family-owned restaurant, Mollica’s Italian Market & Deli opened in 1987.

Mollica’s has an outstanding menu, an Italian marketplace, a deli where you can create and buy your meals and catering, as well as a banquet facility where you may book an event or party for up to thirty people.

Situated in Garden of The Gods Plaza, Mollica’s offers your taste buds sandwiches, pasta, lasagna, and more utilizing fresh ingredients at reasonable prices and also has a kids menu.

Address: 985 Garden of the Gods Road, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Mollica’s Italian Market and Deli

Dat’s Italian

Dat’s Italian, owned and operated by a family since 2010, and it is just 3 miles from beautiful downtown Colorado Springs.

The restaurant’s primary focus is to serve authentic and delicious Italian food in a comfortable atmosphere.

Including fresh-cut pasta, popular menu items at Dat’s Italian include chicken cacciatore, green caesar salad, sausage, pepper pasta, eggplant parmesan, and classic meatballs and spaghetti.

They also have a wine list and a full bar with signature cocktails for you to try. Visit Dat’s Italian to try some delicious food.

Address: 2514 W Colorado Avenue, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Dat’s Italian

Ristorante Del Lago

If you want a romantic dining experience with an Italian backdrop, visit Ristorante del Lago at Broadmoor. Inspired by the best of Italian culinary regions, this setting was created by designer Adam D. Tihany.

An enticing menu of old-world favorites integrated with the restaurant’s timeless ambiance provides the perfect setting to dine with a partner or friends.

Ristorante Del Lago offers flavorful wood-fired pizza, a variety of rotisserie meats, and freshly made pasta daily. Their Homemade gelato and cannoli are the most delightful method to end your meal.

The restaurant’s warm interior decor, which includes exposed wood beams, leather banquettes, terra cotta tiles, custom walnut millwork, and an outdoor/indoor fireplace, is meant to evoke the opulent villas of Lake Como.

Address: 1 Lake Avenue, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Ristorante Del Lago

Pizzeria Rustica

Pizzeria Rustica Housed in a historic building dating back to 1889, this Italian restaurant frequented by locals stands out from the rest.

The menu includes Neapolitan-style pizza, sandwiches, calzones, and salads. Plus, you will love their excellent selection of beers on tap.

San Marzano tomatoes and Tipo 00 Flour are imported; however, toppings and additional ingredients are sourced from sustainable local farmers.

There is a beautiful atmosphere at Pizzeria Rustica, with friendly staff, a small outdoor patio, as well as a working fireplace. You will surely find authentic Italian food here that is second to none.

Address: 2527 W Colorado Avenue, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Pizzeria Rustica

Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano

Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano, situated in The Promenade Shops of Briargate, is a popular chain offering quality Italian cuisine.

What’s special here is that you will find an entirely gluten-free menu that includes appetizers, pizza, salads, sauces, and entrées.

The Half & Half menu at the Biaggi’s is an excellent way to enjoy a delicious lunch at a reasonable price. Select a half salad like their spinach, a bowl of soup, half pizza, or half sandwiches like roasted avocado and turkey from the menu.

One popular segment of the Biaggi’s is their monthly chef features, in which their culinary team works together to bring diners new and seasonal dishes.

Address: 1805 Briargate Pkwy, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Biaggi’s Ristorante Italiano

Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana

Among the Italian restaurants in Colorado Springs, Basil & Barley Pizzeria Napoletana specializes in traditional pizza.

Originating in Naples, Italy, the restaurant serves Neapolitan pizza made the traditional way.

Basil & Barley uses only the freshest and finest ingredients; pizza making begins with dough that is stretched, kneaded, and rested to exact specifications.

They take great pride in baking their pizza in their authentic Acunto Neapolitan ovens imported from Naples.

In addition to the signature handmade pizza of Basil & Barley, it offers Neapolitan fried starters, wings, salads, homemade desserts, and an exclusive menu of cocktails, wine, and draft beers.

Address: 9278 Forest Bluffs View, Colorado Springs, CO

Check Website: Basil & Barley Pizzeria

Mici Handcrafted Italian

Established in 2004, Mici Handcrafted Italian is a family-owned, fast-casual chain based in Denver, Colorado. Its seventh location in Colorado Springs is at the King Soopers Center at Briargate.

They have award-winning Italian food available if you’re ready for a quick meal or want it delivered straight to your home or office.

Kinds of pasta, handmade pizza, lasagna, gelato, and salads are available for takeout, catering, and delivery at Mici Handcrafted Italian. Various drinks are available, including iced tea, fruit juice, and wine.

Address: 9275 N Union Blvd 3140, Colorado Springs
Check Website: Mici Handcrafted Italian

Il Vicino

Founded in 1992 in Albuquerque, New Mexico, Il Vicino expanded to Colorado Springs as well as other locations. This has become a favorite place for Italian pizza among the city’s locals.

The restaurant is best known for its wood oven pizza, but other Italian classics such as paninis, calzones, baked lasagna, and classic pasta dishes can also find on the menu.

Everything on the menu is prepared with quality and fresh ingredients, nicely paired with selections of craft beers, premium wines (a should-try!), and delicious dessert spreads

Address: 5214 N Nevada Ave, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Il Vicino

Luigi’s Restaurant Colorado Springs

Leo and Anne Cervetti launched 1958 this family-owned restaurant, named after their grandfather of Leo.

Relax in a peaceful environment with simple indoor seating; the menu at the Luigi’s consists of appetizers, pizza, spaghetti, and an extensive pasta list.

Located just 4 minutes from downtown, Luigi’s is one of the best Italian restaurants in Colorado Springs, and It is an excellent choice for families or groups of friends.

Address: 947 S Tejon Sreet, Colorado Springs, CO

Check Website: Luigi’s Restaurant Colorado Springs

Stellina Pizza Cafe

This small cafe is tucked away in the street of downtown’s quaint Middle Shooks Run neighborhood at Colorado Springs.

In addition to Roman-style pizza, their menu includes homemade pesto spaghetti and pasta dishes, including starters (like focaccia, and burrata), risotto, and macaroni.

Additionally, Stellina Pizza Cafe offers organic and non-GMO, vegetarian, and vegan options whenever possible to ensure every visitor’s delicious and peaceful experience.

Address: 749 E Willamette Avenue, Colorado Springs, CO
Check Website: Stellina Pizza Café

Note: Since all the information in this article is based on the date of publication, for some reason (health, economic, social), these businesses may be temporarily or permanently closed or moved to another location.